UGC isn't dead, but the version most agencies are selling probably is
By James Massey · 2 min read
UGC fees have climbed while performance hasn't. James Massey on why brands seeing real returns are spending more selectively, not spending less.
# UGC isn't dead. But the way brands are buying it needs to change.
Your agency is probably telling you to double down on UGC. Spend more, produce more creative and keep feeding the algorithm. It's the cheat code to growth.
The problem is that the market has shifted. UGC fees have climbed and, for many brands, performance hasn't followed.
For a while, increasing creative volume felt like a straightforward way to improve paid social performance. More assets meant more opportunities to find winning content, test different angles and keep campaigns fresh. But that thinking has created a market where brands are often paying more for creative without seeing a corresponding improvement in results.
The cost doesn't match the return
The cost per asset rarely offers the efficiencies needed to justify the investment.
We see and hear it every time we get under the hood of a brand's account. The pattern is consistent: rising creator fees, increasing production budgets and growing volumes of content, but little evidence that the additional spend is improving performance.
Creators and agents have done well out of this model. But CFOs and CMOs are left wondering why customer acquisition costs and CPMs keep climbing, CTRs keep falling and creative volume continues to increase.
At some point, brands need to question whether they're buying better creative or simply buying more of it.
More content doesn't fix the problem
The answer is usually straightforward. More content doesn't fix a broken brief, a saturated format or a creator who can't evidence they drive anything beyond a view.
If the underlying creative idea isn't right, producing another twenty variations won't necessarily change the outcome. If the creator isn't relevant to the audience, increasing the fee or output won't make that partnership more valuable.
Without proper measurement, brands can end up repeating the same approach, spending more each month and expecting a different result.
What's working
The brands seeing real returns right now aren't necessarily spending less. They're spending more selectively.
Fewer creators, stronger audience and brand fit, better commercial negotiation and more meaningful data behind every decision.
They're looking beyond follower counts and asset volume to understand which creators can genuinely influence an audience, what content performs and where additional investment is justified.
UGC isn't dead. But the version your agency is selling you probably is.
Learn more about how Gravitas builds creator-led acquisition programmes through our influencer marketing service.