James Massey on why influencer rates are still set badly, and the non-negotiables he applies when negotiating for talent and for brands.
# Influencer pricing needs more than a follower count
Influencer rates are too often still set on follower count, past popularity or, in some cases, no real rationale at all.
Deals get made in the hope that someone with a quota to hit, or without the experience to push back, simply agrees. The result is that everyone ends up disappointed.
Budgets are wasted. Brands invoke termination clauses. Agencies hit a P&L high one month, scramble for the next deal and find themselves chasing the same brand again a year later.
I've seen it all, and much of it comes down to a lack of commercial discipline when agreeing fees.
My non-negotiables
Before agreeing to a creator partnership, there are a number of things I want to understand. These aren't optional extras. They're the foundations of a commercially sensible negotiation.
- Request story insights, including link clicks. Views and reach only tell part of the story. Link clicks help demonstrate whether an audience is taking action.
- Request audience demographics. Understand who the creator is actually reaching, including age, gender and location, and whether that matches the brand's target customer.
- Check the date stamp. I still receive insights that are over a year old. Audience profiles and performance change, so historical data shouldn't automatically justify today's fee.
- Benchmark CPM, CPC, CPV and CTR. Look at the relevant metrics for the campaign objective and use them to understand whether the proposed rate is reasonable.
- Look for engagement pod trends. Engagement needs to be genuine. Unusual patterns in comments and interactions can raise questions about how an audience is responding.
- Look for genuine buying signals in comments. Are people asking about the product, pricing and where to buy, or simply leaving generic reactions?
- Negotiate with data and insight. Every fee should have a rationale that both sides can understand.
- Learn to say no. Walk away when expectations are unrealistic, pricing has no supporting rationale or greed gets in the way of a sensible partnership.
Why it matters
I work both as an agent and as a consultant, supporting talent as well as large brands with their influencer marketing. That gives me visibility of both sides of the negotiation.
For me, it all comes down to sustainable growth, for the talent and the brand.
That means educating creators about the metrics brands are measuring, how their rates are calculated and why those rates may fluctuate over time. It also means helping brands understand that the cheapest deal isn't always the best value.
A healthy influencer market needs both sides to understand the commercial reality. Better information leads to better negotiations, stronger partnerships and relationships that last beyond a single campaign.
Learn more about how Gravitas builds creator-led acquisition programmes through our influencer marketing service.