← All news
Insight

What actually works in influencer marketing

By James Massey · 2 min read

Dan Stevenson on what years of running influencer budgets have taught him: influence over followers, relationships over transactions.

# I've spent years running influencer budgets. Here's what actually works.

I've spent years running influencer budgets, across creator partnerships and paid amplification of creator content. I've seen what drives growth, what wastes money and where brands often get their approach wrong.

The biggest lesson is that successful influencer marketing has very little to do with chasing the biggest numbers.

Influence, not followers

You don't win because someone has followers. You win because someone has influence.

Big audience doesn't automatically mean buying intent. High views don't guarantee revenue. And going viral doesn't necessarily translate into sustainable growth.

Data matters, just not always the data people obsess over.

The most valuable insights rarely come from vanity metrics alone. They come from understanding which creators consistently drive outcomes, organically, through brand partnerships and when spend is put behind their content.

That requires more than looking at a media kit or an engagement rate. It takes experience, commercial understanding and the ability to interpret what the insights are actually telling you. You need to know what good looks like, what is repeatable and what is simply a one-off result.

What became obvious

After years of spending, testing and managing programmes, a few things became clear:

  • Niche creators over celebrity creators. More often than people expect, relevance and audience trust matter more than scale.
  • Repetition over one-off sponsorships. Consistent exposure helps build familiarity and gives partnerships time to deliver.
  • Creator authenticity over perfect brand control. The strongest content feels natural to the creator, not like a corporate advert.
  • Relationships over transactions. The best talent stays longer when you invest in the relationship. In a competitive market, that can mean better outcomes and lower costs over time.
  • Purposeful recruitment over mass spending. A carefully selected group of creators is often more valuable than a large roster without a clear rationale.
  • Long-term thinking over short-term box ticking. Influencer marketing should contribute to wider growth, not simply help a team hit its monthly activity target.

Why we work this way

Most of these lessons came from years on the brand side, managing real budgets, performance pressure and growth targets. It's why we approach influencer marketing differently: not as a campaign to execute, but as a growth lever built on experience, relationships and commercial outcomes.

Many agencies simply haven't lived that first-hand. We have, and that experience shapes how we build programmes, select talent and measure success.

Learn more about how Gravitas builds creator-led acquisition programmes through our influencer marketing service.

Ready to scale your influencer channel?

Enquire now

Contact Us →