← All news
Insight

Influencer Agency or In-House Team: Which Is Right for Your Brand?

By James Massey · 2 min read

Both models can work well. The right one depends on how many creators you manage, how fast you need to move and how much of the relationship work you want to own.

Between us, we have run influencer programmes inside large brands and for clients at the agency, so we have seen both sides of this decision. Neither is the obvious winner. Each suits a different stage of a brand.

What an in-house hire gives you

Someone inside your business knows your product, your tone and your priorities better than any outsider can. They sit close to the rest of the marketing team and can turn feedback around quickly. The trade-off is that one person, or a small team, can only manage so many creators at once. They also start from their own contacts, so a new hire in a new category often begins with a short list.

What an agency adds

An agency arrives with existing creator relationships, current rate knowledge and a process that is already running. That matters most on pricing, where knowing what a creator realistically charges saves real money, and on speed, because briefs go out and content comes back without a hiring period. An agency also sees what is working across many brands, which a single team rarely does.

How the costs compare

An in-house role is a salary plus tools, management time and the cost of getting it wrong. An agency is a retainer or a fee structure on top of creator costs. On paper the agency can look more expensive. In practice, the comparison should include what the in-house route costs in time to hire, time to build a creator network and mistakes on rates.

When in-house makes sense

It works well for brands with high, steady volume, a large internal creative team and a long-term plan to build a community of ambassadors.

# When an agency makes sense

An agency suits brands at the start of their journey and brands that are well into it.

If you’re launching a first programme, an agency gives you a working process, creator relationships and rate knowledge from day one, so you can test influencer without building a team first.

If you’re an established brand, an agency can add capacity and specialist skill that a small internal team can’t cover. That means managing a large creator roster, running partnership ads at scale, negotiating rates across many creators at once, or launching in new markets. It also suits brands whose campaigns come in bursts around launches and seasonal peaks, where a full-time team would sit underused for part of the year.

The deciding factor is the gap you need to fill, whatever the size of the brand.

If you are weighing it up, our influencer marketing service page shows how we work with brands, and you can get in touch to talk through which route fits.

Ready to scale your influencer channel?

Enquire now

Contact Us →