Daniel Stevenson on why pricing a creator beyond what their stats support loses the brand early, and how fair pricing builds repeat business over years.
Follower count is a dead metric in influencer marketing, and we say so often. That still leaves a question some agents and creators seem to skip, which is whether the fee matches what sits under the bonnet. This week we were quoted a five-figure fee for an account with fewer than 20,000 followers, and the stats behind it gave us no way to justify the price to a brand.
The budget it competes with
Influencer marketing sits in the same budget conversation as Meta, TikTok and the other paid channels. A creator fee has to stand up against what those channels deliver for the same money, so the questions to ask are whether the creator gives the brand more efficient reach, engagement, clicks and conversions than the alternatives. If the underlying numbers don't support the price, there is no marketing rationale to take back to the person holding the budget, and adding a premium to the fee doesn't change that.
What overpricing costs
Pricing a creator above what their performance can justify makes it very hard for a brand to come back and activate them again. A first campaign that can't make its numbers work usually ends the conversation, so the quick win on one deal often costs the longer relationship. Brands return to creators who deliver results at a fair price, and agents who get the pricing right and show the value tend to build partnerships that last for years.
We couldn't make this week's quote work, and the creator is welcome to come back to us once the pricing reflects the numbers. Price your talent properly and we will work with you for years. Price them unrealistically and you may never get your foot in the door.
One question for agents
Some deals we see limit the paid spend a brand can put behind a creator's content to the amount of the creator's fee. We can't see the rationale for that, particularly when the content is performing, and we would like to hear the thinking behind it.
Learn more about how Gravitas prices creators on performance through our influencer marketing service.